Skip to content
LoudCrowd

Website Redesign South Yorkshire: SEO and Development Checks Before You Sign

· Managing Director· Updated 20 November 2026

A new website is one of the few marketing projects that can lose you customers. A web design agency can deliver a new website design that looks far better than the old one and still wipe out years of Google rankings and organic traffic in the week it goes live, because nobody planned for search before the design work started.

This checklist takes an hour to cover in a sales meeting, and it protects the traffic you already have. It applies to any web design agency, whether it is in Sheffield, elsewhere in the region or further afield, and whether it calls itself a web agency, a website design studio or a digital marketing agency. If you are also deciding whether one agency should handle your search marketing and ads as well as the website, see full-service agency or SEO specialist. If your rankings matter to the business, our SEO service for South Yorkshire businesses can sit alongside your web design agency during the redesign.

1. Who owns the domain, hosting and accounts after website development?

Settle this first, and get the answer in the contract before any design or development work begins.

  • The domain name should be registered in your business’s name, on an account you can log in to. If the design agency registers it on its own account, leaving them later can become a negotiation.
  • Hosting should be either on your account or set out clearly in the design services contract, with a way to move the website if you leave.
  • Google Analytics and Google Search Console should belong to your own Google account, with the web agency added as a user. Not the other way round.

Google’s guidance on hiring an SEO makes a point that applies to web designers too: “you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire”. If the website agency holds every login, you hold all the risk and none of the keys. Ask now, while everyone is still friendly.

2. URL migration: will they map every old URL to a 301 redirect?

This is the check that matters most in any redesign, and the one most often skipped, especially when web design and development are quoted separately from search work.

If the URL structure changes in the new design, which it usually does, and on an ecommerce website with hundreds of product URLs it almost always does, each old URL needs a 301 redirect to the most relevant page on the new website. Your homepage and main service pages come first. Google’s guide to moving a site says to “prepare a URL mapping from the current URLs to their corresponding new format” and then redirect from the old URLs to the new ones. It also confirms that “301 and other permanent redirects don’t cause a loss in PageRank”.

Finding the URLs that carry your SEO

To find the URLs worth mapping, Google suggests starting with your sitemap, the pages that get the most traffic in your analytics, and the pages other websites link to, which Search Console shows you.

Put three questions to the web design team: who builds the redirect map, when will I see it, and who tests it once the new website is live? If the answer is vague, or they say redirects are not needed, treat that as a warning sign, and ask what experience they have with redirects on a website of your size. “We’ll sort the redirects later” is how a lot of traffic graphs end up looking like a cliff edge.

Notes and analysis on a desk

3. How will the staging site be kept out of Google during the web redesign?

Web design agencies build a new design on a staging copy of the website before it goes live. If Google finds and indexes that copy, you can end up with two versions of your website competing, or half-finished design pages appearing in search results.

The safest way is a password. Google’s page on controlling what you share says that if you have private content, “you need to password protect it to ensure only authorized users can access it”.

A robots.txt block on its own is not enough. Google’s noindex guidance explains that if a page is blocked by robots.txt, the crawler “will never see the noindex rule, and the page can still appear in search results, for example if other pages link to it”.

Then settle the reverse question: who removes the password, the noindex tags and any robots.txt block on go-live day? A new website that goes live still carrying its staging noindex tag will drop out of Google entirely, and this is one of the most common go-live mistakes.

4. Which CMS suits small businesses, and can you edit it yourself?

The content management system decides how easily you can add pages, edit titles and meta descriptions, set redirects and fix problems without paying the web agency each time.

Why many Sheffield agencies pick one CMS

Find out which CMS the web design agency proposes and why. Many agencies, in Sheffield as anywhere, build every website on the same system. That is fine if it suits you and a problem if it does not. Check that you will be able to edit page titles, meta descriptions, headings and URLs, add redirects, and add new pages without a developer. Ask for a login to a demo website so you can try editing a page before you sign. A custom system only the agency can edit is a lock-in, whatever its other merits.

If you are weighing up the two most common options for a small business, our guide to Wix vs WordPress compares them for a UK small business.

5. How fast will the website design be on a phone?

Why speed matters to local businesses

Most local searches, whether for a Sheffield plumber or a Barnsley accountant, happen on phones, and a slow website loses people before it has a chance to sell to them. Speed affects conversion as well as rankings: if you pay for PPC ads, every slow landing page wastes part of that spend.

Google publishes recommended thresholds for its Core Web Vitals: Largest Contentful Paint under 2.5 seconds, Interaction to Next Paint under 200 milliseconds, and Cumulative Layout Shift under 0.1. Check whether the developers test the design against those numbers on a mobile connection, and whether they will share the results before the website goes live.

Watch for heavy video backgrounds, sliders and large uncompressed images in the website design. They look impressive in a meeting room on fast wifi and much less so on a phone in a car park.

Reviewing figures on a phone

6. Will your content and rankings survive the new design?

A new design often cuts text to look cleaner, especially when a project is led by a brand refresh and the web design comes before the words. If the page that ranks for your main service loses most of its words, its headings and its answers to customer questions, it may lose its ranking with them. The same goes for navigation and internal linking: if the new design drops menu links to pages that bring in organic traffic, those pages lose the signals that helped them rank.

Get the web design agency to list which existing pages are being kept, merged or dropped in the new design, and why. Pages that bring in traffic or enquiries should not be deleted or gutted without a conscious decision. A cleaner design is lovely right up until the page that paid the bills disappears from it.

7. What should web designers check on go-live day?

Agree a go-live checklist in writing with the web design team. At minimum:

  • The staging password, noindex tags and any robots.txt block are removed.
  • Every redirect in the map works, with no chains or loops.
  • The XML sitemap lists the new URLs and is submitted in Google Search Console.
  • Analytics is recording visits and enquiry form submissions.
  • Your Search Console verification still works. Google’s site move guide reminds you to keep the verification file if you use that method.
  • Contact forms, phone links and click-to-call buttons work on a phone, and any conversion tracking (including PPC conversion tags) still fires.

Then agree who watches Search Console for the next few weeks after the new website goes live. Google’s site move guide says to “monitor the traffic on both the old and new URLs”.

Budget for redesign services up front in Sheffield

Redirect mapping, staging protection and go-live checks add time to a website design project, and a quote that leaves them out is cheaper for a reason. When you compare web design and development prices from agencies in Sheffield and nearby towns, check what each one includes for search. Our guide to how much a website costs in the UK explains what drives the price, so you can see where the differences come from.

A good web design agency will welcome this checklist, in Sheffield or anywhere else. If one is defensive about it, it is better to find out before you sign than after the new website is live.

Get in touch

Ready when you are

Tell us what you are trying to rank for and we will look at the site and the search results before we reply. You get a straight answer, including if SEO is not the right spend for you yet.

Call0114 697 4482Emailinfo@loudcrowd.agency
Post and meetings by appointmentCourtwood House, Silver Street, Sheffield S1 2DD

No sales sequence, no chasing. One reply from the consultant who would run the work.