Skip to content
LoudCrowd

WooCommerce or Shopify for SEO? An Honest Comparison for UK Stores

· Managing Director

Ask which ecommerce platform is better for SEO and you will get confident answers in both directions. Shopify fans point to how little can go wrong. WooCommerce fans point to how much you can change. Both are right, and that is the useful part: the platforms differ less in what Google can rank than in who has to do the work, and how much freedom they have while doing it.

We work on both, so this comparison is built from what each platform’s own documentation says, set against what matters for search. For help with a WooCommerce store, see our WooCommerce SEO service. For Shopify, our Shopify SEO guides go into the detail.

The real difference: who maintains what

Shopify is hosted. Shopify runs the servers, the security updates and the core software. You manage products, content, theme settings and apps.

WooCommerce runs on your own WordPress site. WooCommerce’s server recommendations start: “Before you install WordPress and WooCommerce, verify that your hosting environment meets the following requirements.” Hosting, updates, backups and speed are yours to arrange, or your developer’s.

For SEO, that is the whole story in miniature. A Shopify store is harder to break and harder to bend. A WooCommerce store can be built exactly as you want, and can also be built very badly.

URLs and site structure

Shopify uses fixed paths for products and collections. Its help page on URL redirects refers to “fixed Shopify paths: /products, /collections, /collections/all”. You choose the handle after the prefix, but the prefix itself stays.

WooCommerce gives you choices. Its permalinks documentation says: “You can choose from four permalink base options for your products.” The default category base is product-category, which you can change.

Does a fixed prefix hurt rankings? Not in itself. Google’s guide to ecommerce URL structure cares about consistency more than wording, and even says: “If you’re using an ecommerce platform, you can most likely skip this section, as the platform has most likely already considered these issues for you.” What matters more is how many versions of each page exist. The same guide advises: “Minimize the number of alternative URLs that return the same content.” On Shopify that usually means products reachable through several collection paths. On WooCommerce it usually means filter and sorting parameters. The causes differ; the fix in both is one clear URL per page.

The flexibility cuts both ways on WooCommerce. Its own documentation warns: “Changing permalink structures updates the URLs of existing products. Any previously shared links or search engine indexes pointing to the old URLs will return 404 errors unless you set up redirects.”

Notes and analysis on a desk

Sitemaps and robots.txt

Shopify does both for you. Its help page on sitemaps says: “All Shopify stores automatically generate a sitemap.xml file that contains links to all your products, primary product image, pages, collections, and blog posts.” For robots.txt, Shopify’s developer docs say “Shopify generates a default robots.txt file that works for most stores”, and you can override it with a robots.txt.liquid template if you need to.

WooCommerce relies on WordPress, which has generated sitemaps since version 5.5. WordPress’s announcement says: “With version 5.5., WordPress will expose a sitemap index at /wp-sitemap.xml.” Many stores replace that with an SEO plugin’s sitemap, which is fine, as long as only one is submitted in Search Console.

One WordPress setting deserves a warning of its own. Under Settings, Reading, the Discourage search engines box adds a noindex tag to every page. It is often ticked while a site is being built and forgotten at launch. If a new WooCommerce store is not appearing in Google, check that box first.

Redirects

Both platforms can do redirects. They work differently.

Shopify has a built-in redirect manager. Its help says: “When you change a URL on your Shopify store, you can create a URL redirect to ensure your customers can still find what they’re looking for.” It also notes: “You can redirect only from broken URLs.” So a URL that still loads a page cannot be redirected until that page is removed.

WooCommerce has no redirect screen in WordPress itself, so most stores use a plugin or rules at the server level, and someone has to own them. That matters most when you restructure categories or move platforms. Our migration SEO checklist covers redirect mapping for a move to Shopify.

Reviewing figures on a phone

Speed and add-ons

On both platforms, extra features come from add-ons: apps on Shopify, plugins on WooCommerce. Each one can add scripts and slow the store down, and speed affects how many visitors stay long enough to buy.

Shopify controls the hosting, so the main speed decisions are your theme, your images and how many apps load on each page.

WooCommerce puts more of it in your hands: the hosting plan, caching, the theme and every plugin. A well-hosted, lightly built WooCommerce store can be very fast. A cheap host with forty plugins will not be, and no amount of SEO work fixes that. Our WooCommerce SEO checklist covers what to check.

Structured data and content

Product structured data helps Google show prices, availability and reviews in results. On both platforms, what you get depends on your theme and plugins or apps, and it changes when you change them. Whichever platform you use, test your product pages with Google’s Rich Results Test after any theme change.

For content, WooCommerce has the edge if you publish a lot. It sits on WordPress, which was built for publishing, so guides, category copy and the shop share one system and one domain. Shopify has a blog and pages, which cover most stores’ needs, with less flexibility in layout.

Should you switch platforms for SEO?

Rarely for SEO alone. A move changes URLs, templates and often content, and each change is a chance to lose rankings. Switch when the platform is holding the business back for other reasons, such as maintenance you cannot keep up with, features you cannot add or costs that no longer make sense, and plan the move carefully.

If you are choosing from scratch:

  • Choose Shopify if you want the platform to handle hosting, security and the technical basics, and you can work within its structure.
  • Choose WooCommerce if you need control over URLs, content and features, and you have someone, in-house or a developer, who will maintain it.
  • On either, the work that moves rankings is the same: category pages that match real searches, unique product copy, one URL per page, working redirects and a fast site.

If you sell from a physical shop as well as online, our guide for retailers who also have a shop covers showing in-store stock on Google, which works on both platforms through Merchant Center.

Get in touch

Ready when you are

Tell us what you are trying to rank for and we will look at the site and the search results before we reply. You get a straight answer, including if SEO is not the right spend for you yet.

Call0114 697 4482Emailinfo@loudcrowd.agency
Post and meetings by appointmentCourtwood House, Silver Street, Sheffield S1 2DD

No sales sequence, no chasing. One reply from the consultant who would run the work.